Sign Up   |   Welcome Guest  |  Login  

Car Articles

Read articles on cars and car industry. Get fully updated on all information related to cars. Read exciting happening in the Indian and Global Car industry, tips to help you and more...


Rate This Page

Difference Between Being Turbocharged or Supercharged


You must have often heard about the cars that comes with turbocharged engines or supercharged engine. But have you ever wondered what that means? Or, have you ever given thought on their functionality and the technicality involved in both these engines?

These two types of engines are very different from each other. But they serve a common purpose, to deliver more horsepower. Both the engines ensure that more air goes into the combustion chamber, resulting in a more powerful explosion which eventually creates power. But the difference lies in the way they do it to give you an exciting driving experience.

Let’s discuss the way the turbocharger functions. A turbocharger uses the exhaust pressure to increase air to the combustion chamber. When the engine gets revved up, the exhaust pressure hits the turbocharger impeller creating a turbine-like effect. This system helps the direct flow of fresh air to the combustion chamber which also makes it possible to add more fuel, increasing the power and torque output of the engine.

Having a turbocharged engine fitted to your car can benefit your car in many ways. Power is being produced without any extra effort from the engine. The air density can also be increased with the addition of intercoolers, which can cool the air even before the turbo gets into the combustion chamber that allows an even greater increase in power. Moreover, a turbocharged engine enables to change the amount of boost available. In some models, this can be achieved even while driving, allowing you to fine-tune the power you need.

The size of the turbocharger is very important. The smaller the turbocharger is, the faster the boost is. Again, it will also come at lower speed as a small turbine will need a smaller volume of air to get the proper tempo compared to a large turbine.

The turbocharged engine has its disadvantages too. The biggest of them is the turbocharger is the uneven power-band. At low RPM's (lower than 4500RPM) the engine is not producing enough exhaust pressure for the turbocharger to add power. This is called the turbo lag. But, once it gets going, it delivers enormous energy. This energy is so massive that a badly setup turbocharger can be dangerous because the abrupt and dramatic increase in power can cause the handling characteristics of the car to change. The older Porsche 911 Turbos are good illustration of this. These cars used to swing the back-end out if the driver was unaware of the turbo boost hit.

Another drawback of the turbocharged engine is its maintenance. There are more moving parts in a turbocharged engine compared to a supercharger, and some turbochargers require cool down time after rigorous use before the engine can be shut off.

The turbocharged engine was invented by Swiss engineer Alfred Buchi. His patent for a turbocharger was applied for use in 1905. But the first turbocharged engine was manufactured in 1938 and the first production turbocharged automobile engines came from General Motors in 1962. The world's first production turbo diesel cars were the Mercedes 300SD and the Peugeot 604, which were introduced in 1978. Today, many automotive diesels are turbocharged. Most Mahindra cars come with turbocharged engines. Mercedes plans to install turbocharger on all their engines for all car models. Many car models including the Tata Indica come with turbocharged engines.

On the other hand, supercharging means pump that forces air into an engine for many, but, in common usage, it refers to pumps that are driven directly by the engine, as opposed to turbochargers that are driven by the pressure of the exhaust gases.

The supercharged engine is powered by the engine through a belt/pulley system. The belt rotates the impeller inside the supercharger that pushes more air into the combustion chamber. The advantage of having a supercharged engine is that it's very easy and simple to use. Besides, the power is readily available and it doesn't require special cooling or maintenance as in turbocharged engines. In addition, a supercharged engine is more reliable than a turbocharged engine.

The supercharged engine delivers an even and steady boost throughout the entire power-band that results in a more conventional handling and power at low as well as at high RPM's. The negative aspect of supercharging is that it uses a small amount of power from the engine all of the time. Paradoxically, the more power the supercharger produces, the more power it pulls from the system.

Supercharger can be divided into two types in terms of the method of compression: positive-displacement and dynamic compressors. The first type delivers a reasonable constant level of boost regardless of engine speed (RPM), whereas the latter can deliver increasing boost with increasing engine speed.

Gottlieb Daimler was the inventor of the supercharger. The first supercharged cars were the 6/20 horsepower and 10/35 horsepower Mercedes, which were introduced in the 1921 Berlin Motor Show. In the late 1920s, Bentley made a supercharged version of the Bentley 4.5 Litre road car. The Mercedes-Benz SLK, the Ford Mustang and the Jaguar XKR have supercharged engine.